UML tools comparison

I have many years C++ experience but I am novice in UML. I learn and use the 
UML in  embedded real-time application development.

Can some proficient UML users help me by showing a comparison table of some 
sort so that I can decide which UML tool I should select for real-time C++ 
applications? AND/OR Share your experience with your UML tools? 

Enterprise Architect vs Rational Rose
http://consulting.dthomas.co.uk/ooad_articles_resources/Comparison_of_UML_Modelling_Tools.pdf

Hi,
you can try this link too:
http://www.uml-embedded.com/
Schwob
Microremovecontrolremoveler at gmremoveail.com


Mertiof wrote:
> I have many years C++ experience but I am novice in UML. I learn and
use the
> UML in  embedded real-time application development.
>
> Can some proficient UML users help me by showing a comparison table
of some
> sort so that I can decide which UML tool I should select for
real-time C++
> applications? AND/OR Share your experience with your UML tools?

try:
http://www.uml-embedded.com/

Mertiof wrote:
> I have many years C++ experience but I am novice in UML. I learn and use the 
> UML in  embedded real-time application development.
> 
> Can some proficient UML users help me by showing a comparison table of some 
> sort so that I can decide which UML tool I should select for real-time C++ 
> applications? AND/OR Share your experience with your UML tools? 
> 
> 
Of course there is Argo UML...
http://argouml.tigris.org/

I don't have anything really nice to say about the tool. It was one of 
those tools that pushed everybody's buttons. The commercial version was 
definitely better, and much more polished. I always got the feeling that 
the developers of the non commercial version of the product fell in to 
the trap of never being satisfied and kept rewriting parts... and that's 
why it's at version 0.16.1.

Brett

I've used Rose for many years. Lately the only support we receive
is the support bill, and after it was aquired by IBM it's near
to impossible to get in contact with the support pages on the net.
I would not buy it again....

In article <420b0f9f$0$14096$afc38c87@news.optusnet.com.au>, <Mertiof> 
says...
> I have many years C++ experience but I am novice in UML. I learn and use the 
> UML in  embedded real-time application development.
> 
> Can some proficient UML users help me by showing a comparison table of some 
> sort so that I can decide which UML tool I should select for real-time C++ 
> applications? AND/OR Share your experience with your UML tools? 
> 
> 
> 

WinA&D is very strong on UML for embedded, real-time systems with features like
full UML modeling, multi-task design, requirements management, C++ code
generation and reengineering of existing C++ to UML class diagrams and
dictionary (using WinTranslator).  You can find product descriptions, screen
shots and pricing at www.excelsoftware.com.  Excel Software provide free
technical support by phone and email so after looking over the web site, email
any WinA&D questions to info@excelsoftware.com.

Mertiof wrote:

> I have many years C++ experience but I am novice in UML. I learn and use the
> UML in  embedded real-time application development.
>
> Can some proficient UML users help me by showing a comparison table of some
> sort so that I can decide which UML tool I should select for real-time C++
> applications? AND/OR Share your experience with your UML tools?

Mertiof wrote:
> I have many years C++ experience but I am novice in UML. I learn and use the 
> UML in  embedded real-time application development.
> 
> Can some proficient UML users help me by showing a comparison table of some 
> sort so that I can decide which UML tool I should select for real-time C++ 
> applications? AND/OR Share your experience with your UML tools? 
Take a look at http://www.oose.de/umltools.htm

regards
   Martin

In comp.software-eng Martin Kaul <mkaul@leuze.de> wrote:
> Take a look at http://www.oose.de/umltools.htm

Martin

precious hint: this is a great list (even Artisan is there)

Maybe they think about inverting that table into "portrait"
because a table of 1000 width x 20 height might not be practical.

-- 
--Peter Hermann(49)0711-685-3611 fax3758 ica2ph@csv.ica.uni-stuttgart.de
--Pfaffenwaldring 27 Raum 114, D-70569 Stuttgart Uni Computeranwendungen
--http://www.csv.ica.uni-stuttgart.de/homes/ph/
--Team Ada: "C'mon people let the world begin" (Paul McCartney)

Peter Hermann wrote:
> In comp.software-eng Martin Kaul <mkaul@leuze.de> wrote:
> 
>>Take a look at http://www.oose.de/umltools.htm
> 
> 
> Martin
> 
> precious hint: this is a great list (even Artisan is there)
This list was the reason we found Artisan - now we use it ;-)

regards
   Martin